Eating Matzah: Difference between revisions

(7 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)

Line 9:

However, the main obligation is learned from the verse "in the evening, you shall eat matzos<ref>See Rambam Hilchos Chametz U'Matzah Chapter 6 Halacha 1 and in the Lechem Mishneh there, and in the citation of the Gemara later in the text.</ref>."

==== During Galus (Exile) ====

=Reasons for the Commandment=

One of the central reasons for eating matzah on Passover is to commemorate the haste of the Exodus from Egypt. As it is stated: "they baked the dough which they had brought out of Egypt into unleavened cakes, for it had not leavened, because they were driven out of Egypt and could not delay"<ref>Exodus 12:39.</ref>. Similarly, it is written: "Seven days you shall eat unleavened bread with it... so that you may remember the day you came out of the land of Egypt... for you departed from the land of Egypt in haste"<ref>Deuteronomy 16:3.</ref>.

Accordingly, the eating of matzah represents the fact that at the time of the Exodus, our ancestors’ dough did not have time to leaven, and they were compelled to bake it as it was—matzah<ref>They brought out dough from Egypt, and baked it into matzot when they arrived at Sukkot; and from the time they left Raamses until they came to Sukkot, the dough did not leaven. Likkutei Torah</ref>.

Although the primary reason for eating matzah is because the dough of the Israelites did not have time to rise when they left Egypt, the Torah commanded the eating of matzah even earlier. Already in the passage of "This month shall be for you"<ref>Exodus 12.</ref>, it is stated: "They shall eat the meat on that night, roasted over fire, and matzot; with bitter herbs they shall eat it," and explicitly: "In the evening, you shall eat matzot." Thus, the commandment to eat matzah preceded the actual event of the hasty departure.

This requires explanation: if the main rationale for eating matzah is that the dough of our ancestors did not leaven until God revealed Himself and redeemed them, as stated, "They baked the dough into unleavened cakes... because they were driven out of Egypt and could not delay,"—how is it possible that the commandment to eat matzah was given before the Exodus itself, in the passage of "This month shall be for you", before the event of the hasty redemption had occurred?

On this matter, three explanations have been given:

'''First explanation:''' The original command, "In the evening, you shall eat matzot," refers only to the first Passover night, when the Israelites were commanded to eat the Paschal offering together with matzah and bitter herbs. By contrast, the eating of matzah during the remaining seven days of Passover stems from the historical event in which the Israelites were forced to leave in haste and therefore baked matzot, as their dough had no time to rise. In other words, the matzah of the first night is due to a divine commandment, whereas the matzah of the subsequent days serves as a memorial to the event.

'''Second explanation:''' A distinction should be made between two types of matzah: matzah eaten before midnight and matzah eaten afterward. Before midnight, it was consumed in fulfillment of God's command as part of the Paschal offering. After midnight, when God revealed Himself and redeemed Israel, their dough did not have time to rise—this gave rise to the "matzah of haste." The commandment we fulfill today, even when we eat matzah before midnight on the Seder night, incorporates both aspects: both the matzah commanded by the Torah and the matzah symbolizing the haste of the redemption.

'''Third explanation'''—and the simplest: Although the commandment to eat matzah was issued before the actual Exodus occurred, this was because God, who knows the future ("declaring the end from the beginning"), knew in advance that the redemption would come in haste and the dough would not have time to leaven. Therefore, He commanded them to eat matzah so that their eating would be not only in response to circumstance but also in fulfillment of a divine precept. For had they eaten matzah merely because their dough had not leavened, it would not have constituted a commandment. Thus, God preemptively issued the command so that what was done under duress (due to the haste of redemption) would also be performed intentionally as a mitzvah<ref>Maamar "Matzah Zo" 5629, Sefer HaMaamarim 5629, p. 132ff; and Maamar "Matzah Zo" 5729.</ref>.

== During Galus (Exile) ==

During galus when we are unable to offer the Pesach sacrifice, there is a dispute in the Gemara whether the mitzvah is from the Torah. However, in halacha, the Gemara follows Rava's opinion that the obligation is from the Torah even during galus:<blockquote>Rava said: "Matzah nowadays is a Torah obligation, while maror is rabbinic. Why is maror different? Because it is written, 'with matzos and maror shall they eat it' - when there is a Pesach offering, there is [an obligation of] maror, and when there is no Pesach offering, there is no [Torah obligation of] maror. But regarding matzah as well, isn't it written 'with matzos and maror shall they eat it'? [For] matzah, the verse returns to it [to obligate it independently], [as it states] 'in the evening you shall eat matzos.' And Rav Acha bar Yaakov says both this [matzah] and that [maror] are rabbinic...A beraisa supports Rava: 'Six days you shall eat matzos, and on the seventh day shall be a solemn assembly to Hashem your G-d' - just as [eating matzah on] the seventh day is optional, so too [on] the six days it is optional... One might think that [eating matzah] on the first night is also optional; the verse therefore states 'with matzos and maror shall they eat it.' I only know [that the obligation applies] when the Beis HaMikdash exists; from where [do I know that it applies] when the Beis HaMikdash does not exist? The verse therefore states: 'in the evening you shall eat matzos' - the verse established it as an obligation." — Pesachim 120a</blockquote>This means that the Torah emphasizes that although both for matzah and maror it says "with matzos and maror shall they eat it," regarding matzah the Torah emphasizes "in the evening you shall eat matzos," indicating that even when there is no Pesach offering, there is an obligation to eat matzah.

Line 28:

Line 45:

== See Also ==

* [[Mivtza Matzah]]

* Mivtza Matzah

* [[Matzah Shemurah]]

* Matzah Shemurah

* [[Machine Matzah]]

* Machine Matzah

* [[Matzah Sheruyah (Gebrokts)]]

* Matzah Sheruyah (Gebrokts)

* [[Matzah L'Talmid]]

* Matzah L'Talmid

== External Links ==

* Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz, '''[https://he.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/3594159#utm_medium=email&utm_source=93_subscription_he&utm_campaign=he&utm_content=content Why Do We Eat Matzah?]'''

== References ==

[[Category: Mitzvos]]

[[Category:Night of the Seder]]

[[he:מצוות אכילת מצה]]

[[Category:Mitzvos]]

@@ Line 9: / Line 9: @@
 However, the main obligation is learned from the verse "in the evening, you shall eat matzos<ref>See Rambam Hilchos Chametz U'Matzah Chapter 6 Halacha 1 and in the Lechem Mishneh there, and in the citation of the Gemara later in the text.</ref>."
-==== During Galus (Exile) ====
+=Reasons for the Commandment=
+One of the central reasons for eating matzah on Passover is to commemorate the haste of the Exodus from Egypt. As it is stated: "they baked the dough which they had brought out of Egypt into unleavened cakes, for it had not leavened, because they were driven out of Egypt and could not delay"<ref>Exodus 12:39.</ref>. Similarly, it is written: "Seven days you shall eat unleavened bread with it... so that you may remember the day you came out of the land of Egypt... for you departed from the land of Egypt in haste"<ref>Deuteronomy 16:3.</ref>.
+Accordingly, the eating of matzah represents the fact that at the time of the Exodus, our ancestors’ dough did not have time to leaven, and they were compelled to bake it as it was—matzah<ref>They brought out dough from Egypt, and baked it into matzot when they arrived at Sukkot; and from the time they left Raamses until they came to Sukkot, the dough did not leaven. Likkutei Torah</ref>.
+Although the primary reason for eating matzah is because the dough of the Israelites did not have time to rise when they left Egypt, the Torah commanded the eating of matzah even earlier. Already in the passage of "This month shall be for you"<ref>Exodus 12.</ref>, it is stated: "They shall eat the meat on that night, roasted over fire, and matzot; with bitter herbs they shall eat it," and explicitly: "In the evening, you shall eat matzot." Thus, the commandment to eat matzah preceded the actual event of the hasty departure.
+This requires explanation: if the main rationale for eating matzah is that the dough of our ancestors did not leaven until God revealed Himself and redeemed them, as stated, "They baked the dough into unleavened cakes... because they were driven out of Egypt and could not delay,"—how is it possible that the commandment to eat matzah was given before the Exodus itself, in the passage of "This month shall be for you", before the event of the hasty redemption had occurred?
+On this matter, three explanations have been given:
+'''First explanation:''' The original command, "In the evening, you shall eat matzot," refers only to the first Passover night, when the Israelites were commanded to eat the Paschal offering together with matzah and bitter herbs. By contrast, the eating of matzah during the remaining seven days of Passover stems from the historical event in which the Israelites were forced to leave in haste and therefore baked matzot, as their dough had no time to rise. In other words, the matzah of the first night is due to a divine commandment, whereas the matzah of the subsequent days serves as a memorial to the event.
+'''Second explanation:''' A distinction should be made between two types of matzah: matzah eaten before midnight and matzah eaten afterward. Before midnight, it was consumed in fulfillment of God's command as part of the Paschal offering. After midnight, when God revealed Himself and redeemed Israel, their dough did not have time to rise—this gave rise to the "matzah of haste." The commandment we fulfill today, even when we eat matzah before midnight on the Seder night, incorporates both aspects: both the matzah commanded by the Torah and the matzah symbolizing the haste of the redemption.
+'''Third explanation'''—and the simplest: Although the commandment to eat matzah was issued before the actual Exodus occurred, this was because God, who knows the future ("declaring the end from the beginning"), knew in advance that the redemption would come in haste and the dough would not have time to leaven. Therefore, He commanded them to eat matzah so that their eating would be not only in response to circumstance but also in fulfillment of a divine precept. For had they eaten matzah merely because their dough had not leavened, it would not have constituted a commandment. Thus, God preemptively issued the command so that what was done under duress (due to the haste of redemption) would also be performed intentionally as a mitzvah<ref>Maamar "Matzah Zo" 5629, Sefer HaMaamarim 5629, p. 132ff; and Maamar "Matzah Zo" 5729.</ref>.
+== During Galus (Exile) ==
 During galus when we are unable to offer the Pesach sacrifice, there is a dispute in the Gemara whether the mitzvah is from the Torah. However, in halacha, the Gemara follows Rava's opinion that the obligation is from the Torah even during galus:<blockquote>Rava said: "Matzah nowadays is a Torah obligation, while maror is rabbinic. Why is maror different? Because it is written, 'with matzos and maror shall they eat it' - when there is a Pesach offering, there is [an obligation of] maror, and when there is no Pesach offering, there is no [Torah obligation of] maror. But regarding matzah as well, isn't it written 'with matzos and maror shall they eat it'? [For] matzah, the verse returns to it [to obligate it independently], [as it states] 'in the evening you shall eat matzos.' And Rav Acha bar Yaakov says both this [matzah] and that [maror] are rabbinic...A beraisa supports Rava: 'Six days you shall eat matzos, and on the seventh day shall be a solemn assembly to Hashem your G-d' - just as [eating matzah on] the seventh day is optional, so too [on] the six days it is optional... One might think that [eating matzah] on the first night is also optional; the verse therefore states 'with matzos and maror shall they eat it.' I only know [that the obligation applies] when the Beis HaMikdash exists; from where [do I know that it applies] when the Beis HaMikdash does not exist? The verse therefore states: 'in the evening you shall eat matzos' - the verse established it as an obligation." — Pesachim 120a</blockquote>This means that the Torah emphasizes that although both for matzah and maror it says "with matzos and maror shall they eat it," regarding matzah the Torah emphasizes "in the evening you shall eat matzos," indicating that even when there is no Pesach offering, there is an obligation to eat matzah.
@@ Line 28: / Line 45: @@
 == See Also ==
+* [[Mivtza Matzah]]
-* Mivtza Matzah
+* [[Matzah Shemurah]]
-* Matzah Shemurah
+* [[Machine Matzah]]
-* Machine Matzah
+* [[Matzah Sheruyah (Gebrokts)]]
-* Matzah Sheruyah (Gebrokts)
+* [[Matzah L'Talmid]]
-* Matzah L'Talmid
 == External Links ==
 * Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz, '''[https://he.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/3594159#utm_medium=email&utm_source=93_subscription_he&utm_campaign=he&utm_content=content Why Do We Eat Matzah?]'''
 == References ==
-[[Category: Mitzvos]]
+{{Passover}}
+[[Category:Night of the Seder]]
+[[he:מצוות אכילת מצה]]
+<references />
+[[Category:Mitzvos]]